The whole point of free speech is not to make ideas exempt from criticism but to expose them to it.

Friday, March 26, 2010

Whatever happened to Fred Phelps?

Haven't heard much about Fred Phelps for a while, but something brought him to mind tonight; don't know what, for sure.

From Wikipedia (Fred Phelps):
He is known for the slogans that he and his ministry use against people he deems sinful, including "God Hates Fags", "Thank God for Dead Soldiers", "America Is Doomed" and "Priests Rape Boys". He claims that God will punish homosexuals as well as various public figures such as Bill O'Reilly, Coretta Scott King, Ronald Reagan, Howard Dean, and anyone else whom his church considers "fag-enablers". He and his group picket military funerals under the apparent conviction that the people being buried have any role in whatever policy he's protesting besides having been killed following orders under it.

He's the very most dangerous kind of demagogue, deluded and with some measure of charisma, apparently. The danger comes not from him, but from those who fear him so much they would be willing to sacrifice their own freedom of speech to stop him from desecrating a funeral.

Fred Phelps is a would-be totalitarian who by his actions creates support for the very totalitarians he says he despises. That's because it is very likely that a very liberal gay Jewish woman on the east coast will pressure her senator to do something that will silence Fred Phelps. Probably already has. And her influence is a hundredfold that of a Phelps supporter.fred_phelps_idiotic_911_message.bmp

I have nothing but contempt for Phelps' politics and tactics, but I defend his right to attempt to bring his disrespect to a funeral. The right to stand on a street corner or in a public cemetery and hold a sign with an execrable message is more necessary to liberty than is the right to hold a funeral without jerks across the street saying the departed is doomed for being killed while under the orders of somebody Phelps doesn't like. Phelps will fade away. Other Phelpses will arise. Only rarely will a right, once surrendered, re-appear.


Wayne Gilbert said...

OK my friend. You corrected the unacceptable use of an apostrophe to attempt a plural. You didn't clean up the weird-ass run-on sentence however. Meanwhile, you didn't publish my comments. Was that because they insulted your abuse of the language?

Bob Newland said...

I think you posted your first comment in the thread above (O M G !).

Professional writers are allowed weird-ass run-on sentences. Always remember: The Koala Tea of Mercy is not strain'd.

Fred Phelps IS gay said...

BALTIMORE, Maryland (AP) - Lawyers for the father of a Marine who died in Iraq say a court has ordered him to pay legal costs for the anti-gay protesters from Kansas who picketed his son's funeral.

The protesters are led by Fred Phelps of Topeka's Westboro Baptist Church. Albert Snyder of York, Pa., had won a $5 million verdict against Phelps, but it was thrown out on appeal.

On Friday, the Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit in Maryland ordered Snyder to pay the costs of Phelps' appeal.

The U.S. Supreme Court agreed earlier this month to consider whether the protesters' provocative messages, which include phrases like "Thank God for dead soldiers," are protected by the First Amendment.

Lawyers say Snyder already is struggling to come up with the fees associated with filing the brief with the high court.

Bob Newland said...

There you have it.